The Florida Keys are paradise for more than just sunseekers and ocean lovers—they’re a hub for key lime pie fans. This sweet-tart dessert has become a must-try for anyone visiting the area, thanks to its roots right here in the Keys. From time-honored recipes to inventive twists, local spots serve pies that are as distinctive as the islands themselves. Ready to discover where to find the very best slices? Let’s make your taste buds the priority of your trip.
Top Key Lime Pie Spots in the Florida Keys
The Florida Keys are the heart and soul of key lime pie. Whether you’re craving a classic slice or a unique twist, this tropical getaway delivers flavors you’ll never forget. Here are some of the best places to savor this iconic dessert.
Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory
Photo by Nextvoyage
If Key Lime Pie were a competition, Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory might just take home the gold medal. Located in Tavernier, this spot welcomes visitors with charm and bright, citrusy vibes. They offer a silky, ultra-creamy pie perfected with a graham cracker crust and just the right balance of tartness and sweetness. You can opt for variations like chocolate-dipped slices or even grab a whole pie to take home. Its fame has even been cemented by countless rave reviews. Check out more about this must-stop at Blond Giraffe’s reviews.
Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe
Situated on Elizabeth Street in Key West, Kermit’s is more than a bakery—it’s an experience in itself. Known for its vibrant lime-green decor and its founder, Kermit, who’s famous for entertaining visitors, this spot serves a pie that’s easily among the best in the area. Each bite blends a velvety texture with a bold lime flavor, capped off with a buttery crust. Bonus points if you pair your slice with their tangy limeade. It’s no surprise that locals and tourists alike flock here. Dive deeper into Kermit’s at Kermit’s reviews.
Burdines in Marathon
Burdines Waterfront in Marathon flips the script with their one-of-a-kind mousse-style key lime pie. This light, airy version is a delightful surprise for those looking to try a new spin on the traditional recipe. Not overly dense, this mousse-style pie melts in your mouth and leaves just a hint of citrus behind. Enjoy it on their outdoor deck overlooking the water—it’s a true Keys experience. Read about others’ experiences here.
Old Town Bakery
For a more understated yet unforgettable slice, visit Old Town Bakery in Key West. Tucked away from the tourist-heavy areas, this spot is a local favorite. Their key lime pie stands out with a gingersnap crust, offering a spicy twist that complements the sweet and tart filling. It’s simple, no-frills, and incredibly satisfying—just the way the locals like it. More details can be found here.
Blue Heaven
Blue Heaven is proof that atmosphere enhances flavor. Known for its eclectic outdoor setting featuring roaming roosters and live music, this Key West icon has become synonymous with their sky-high meringue-topped key lime pie. While the pie itself is a flawless combination of creamy and tangy, it’s the vibe of the place that makes the visit unforgettable. Don’t miss a chance to enjoy dessert under the tropical shade at this legendary spot. Learn more about Blue Heaven here.
Unique Key Lime Pie Varieties
The Florida Keys aren’t just the birthplace of key lime pie—they’re where culinary creativity thrives. Beyond the classic recipes, locals have mastered unique twists on this iconic dessert. Let’s explore some of the most innovative varieties.
Fried Key Lime Pie: A Crispy, Gooey Delight
Ever thought your favorite pie could taste better fried? In the Keys, that dream is a reality. Fried key lime pie elevates the dessert game by wrapping the tangy, creamy filling in a light pastry shell, then frying it to golden perfection. The result? A crunchy exterior that gives way to a warm, gooey center—like the lovechild of a pie and a fritter.
If you’re ready to indulge, head to Burdines Waterfront in Marathon, a local staple known for this signature treat. Other great spots, like Porky’s Bayside in Marathon, also serve up this one-of-a-kind dessert. Fried key lime pie is proof that traditional desserts can still surprise and delight. Explore more great places offering fried pies here.
Key Lime Pie with a Twist: Playful Crusts and Toppings Add Flair
From crusts to toppings, the variations in the Keys elevate key lime pie into an art form. Why stick with graham crackers when you can use gingersnaps for a spiced, crunchy base? Some eateries go a step further, using pretzel crusts for a salty contrast to the sweet-tart filling. It’s the ultimate balance of flavors.
As for toppings, whipped cream plays second fiddle to everything from meringue towering like a tropical cloud to chocolate drizzles that add decadence. Don’t miss Old Town Bakery’s gingersnap crusted version if you’re in Key West—it’s simple yet unforgettable. Want to see how locals innovate their pies? Check out ideas here.
Whether fried, topped with chocolate, or served on a unique crust, key lime pie in the Keys always keeps things interesting. Your next slice might just be your favorite twist yet.
Tips for Enjoying Key Lime Pie in the Keys
There’s nothing quite like a slice of key lime pie enjoyed in the place that birthed it—the Florida Keys. Beyond deciding where to find the best slices, it’s worth knowing how to make your key lime pie experience truly unforgettable. Here are some tips that will elevate your key lime pie adventure in the Keys.
Pairing Suggestions: Drinks or Snacks That Complement Key Lime Pie
Key lime pie is a dessert that shines on its own, but pairing it with the right drink or side makes the flavors pop even more. Think of it as matching a perfect melody to its harmony.
- Cool and Creamy Drinks: Pair your slice with a frosty pina colada or an iced coconut latte for a tropical vibe.
- Wine Pairings: Sparkling brut rosé or a Moscato D’Asti are great choices, balancing the pie’s tartness with their sweet notes. Check out pairing tips from Wine Enthusiast.
- Non-Alcoholic Options: Sipping a floral tea like jasmine or a crisp lemonade highlights flavors without overpowering them.
Want to keep it simple? Fresh-cut tropical fruits like pineapple or mango provide a delicious, natural complement to the pie’s tart lime.
Best Time to Visit: Seasons for Enjoying Key Lime Pie
The Keys are a year-round destination, but certain seasons make enjoying key lime pie even better. With the right timing, you’ll avoid the crowds and soak up the best weather.
- March to May: These spring months are ideal. The weather stays warm but not overly hot, and the Keys are less crowded. Learn more about this perfect spot in time at Travel & Leisure.
- Fall for Deals: Visiting in September or October? Fewer tourists mean you can relax and enjoy your pie at a more leisurely pace.
- Winter Charm: January through March combines mild temperatures with the buzz of tourists. If you don’t mind crowds, enjoying a slice by the waterfront in cooler weather feels magical.
Whether you’re exploring in the peak of summer or the mellow fall season, a slice of key lime pie makes every day in the Keys sweeter.